Notice or pay instead of notice is not required if the:
- employee has less than 13 weeks of continuous employment with the employer;
- employee refuses to work out a notice period or otherwise voluntarily resigns;
- contract of employment has a definite end date; or
- employer has "just cause" to dismiss the employee.
Just Cause
Generally, courts have ruled that just cause may exist if the employee is guilty of serious misconduct, such as theft, violence, insubordination or wilful misconduct. Just cause may also include excessive employee absenteeism, chronic tardiness and other unscheduled absences from work.
The facts and circumstances surrounding the misconduct must be examined carefully. Each case is different. The employee's position and length of service must be considered.
Personality conflicts, general dissatisfaction with performance, petty issues, or one incident of inappropriate behaviour or misconduct, are usually not serious enough for just cause to terminate without notice. In these instances, corrective action may be more appropriate.
Encourage improvement by identifying reasonable performance standards, conducting performance reviews over a reasonable period, and warning the employee of the consequences (such as termination) for failing to meet the required standards. Employers must provide employees a reasonable opportunity to make the improvements or changes needed to retain employment. Employers who do these things have a better case for just cause.
Good record keeping can be helpful in showing due diligence.
Employers who condone or ignore misconduct may be prevented from claiming that the dismissal was for just cause. Condonation means that the behaviour has been largely left unaddressed. An employee must be warned that their behaviour will lead to termination if it is not corrected, and they must be provided reasonable opportunity to correct their behaviour. Otherwise employers won't have a strong case to not provide notice or pay instead of notice, as the employee would not have been made aware that their behaviour was unacceptable.
Employers who are thinking about dismissing an employee for just cause should get legal advice before taking action.
Even if notice is provided, an employer is not allowed to terminate an employee for a reason that is protected under the Act. Protected reasons in various sections of the Act include: filing a complaint, reporting an offense by the employer, illness or injury, requesting modifications or reassignment of job duties to accommodate a disability, requesting a leave, pregnancy or requesting compliance with the legislation.